An Absolute Gem!.
I live in New York city and visit the Cape every year. I dine out regularly in Manhattan and would consider my self a connoisseur. Last summer I happened upon a little place called "Peddler's Grill" off the beaten path in Brewster. I proceeded to have one of the best meals I've ever had, it was that good. The food was super fresh, prepared to perfection, the salad dressing was the best I've ever had...It is by far the best restaurant on Cape Cod and probably one of the best restaurants I've ever been to (and I've traveled extensively) I spent 12 nights on the Cape last year and ate at Peddler's every every one of them...Also it never seems to be crowded which is a welcome change from most other tourist traps in the area... Can't wait to go back!